Shell s practice has now survived for almost half a century and has had a huge influence on how businesses, governments, and other organisations think about and plan for the future. Pdf integrating scenarios into strategic planning at royal. Two, there is a 30% probability that the new distributor will sign the contract. The vision 2040 global scenarios for the oil and gas industry study uses a timehonored monitor deloitte scenario preparation methodology to forecast a panorama of directions the sector may take in the next decades. Objectives 1 and 2 were pursued in a multiple case study involving transdisciplinary research over. The sheer breadth and depth of perspective gained from our scenarios continues to inspire many successful partnerships and initiatives around the world, on individual country levels as well as regional and global. Pdf in the early 1980s, the royal dutchshell group conducted a comprehensive.
What can we learn from scenario planning at shell oil. Then the leaders of royal dutch shell used scenarios to show the supply of oil would eventually need to be restricted by the oil producing countries. In 1965, when quantitative planning was much in vogue, royal dutch shell started experimenting with a different way of looking into the future. The authors, experienced in case study design, development, and method for teaching in an mba program, used the case study approach to create a scenario planning strategy to analyze a companys. To anticipate such changes, royal dutch shell group of compani. The shell scenarios team brings together experts from an array of disciplines to understand versions of the future. The federal highway administration funded volpe to develop for the cape cod. Output from the marketing directors workshop was used to set the vision for the workshop for relationship marketing, the next level of man agement within the marketing department. These scenarios continue to provide useful insights and we draw on them in this booklet. Scenario planning is credited with royal dutch shells leap from the eighth largest oil company to the second largest oil company in two. The scenarios team has produced a joint study with the development research centre drc of chinas state council to examine how natural gas could evolve as a mainstream energy source in china natural gas is the ideal alternative to coal, as it is cleaner, more efficient and easier to transport and store. We have been developing scenarios within shell for almost 50 years.
A scenario planning pilot project on cape cod, massachusetts, to integrate climate change considerations into existing and continuing transportation, land use, coastal zone, and hazard mitigation planning processes. Corporations such as shell pioneered scenario planning in the 1970s as they realised traditional tools of forecasting became strategically dangerous as the environment began to destabilize in the 1950s nelson, 2014. Case studies are narratives that feature real world situations or uses of products or services to demonstrate their value. In the following year, it was finally recommended throughout the.
Following a period in which scenario development was an episodic activity, shell fully integrated scenarios into their strategic planning cycle in the early 1980s. Perhaps the worst temptation in scenario planning is to think. This short film looks at how scenario planning has evolved over 40 years to become today a vital strategic planning tool within and outside of the company. In the past, strategic plans have often considered. The shifts are more local in nature and the group doing the planning will be smaller, but the future will be just as unknown and the need for planning will always be just as important. Strategic foresight and scenario planning for the future why scenarios world is complex political, economic, social, technological, ecological future is uncertain critical uncertainties weak signals forecasts are wrong predetermined elements structure given, only variables are changing possibility vs probability space scenarios are needed global, specific.
Three decades of scenario planning in shell case solution and. Wack, who had studied some of the mystic traditions of india and japan in. Published in 20, this book is a commemoration of four decades of the scenario making practice in shell. Nov 06, 2012 this short film looks at how scenario planning has evolved over 40 years to become today a vital strategic planning tool within and outside of the company. Three decades of scenario planning in shell case analysis. Scenario planning is a strategic planning method that organizations use to develop flexible longterm plans. What we can learn from scenario planning at shell oil leslie martel baer president, energy intersections, llc herb rubenstein executive director, the leeegh asp 2012 1 2. This article is aimed at readers who are using, or have considered using, scenarios as a strategic planning tool and are interested in finding out about another companys experiences in developing and using this technique. It is also referred to as scenario analysis and scenario thinking. Since most investments are irreversible, scenario planning can be combined with real options analysis to identify options in the future, help time the decision to exercise a real option. How do scenarios and forecasting relate to each other. Jan 10, 2018 today, shell boasts a sizeable scenarios team, including experts in energy, climate change, economics, socio. Current practices of scenario planning are largely based on existing literature which utilises scenario planning to develop strategies for the future, primarily considering the assessment of. Shell new zealand keenly followed all the political manifestos of all the major political parties in new zealand and based on that, they did their thorough scenario planning.
What can we learn from scenario planning at shell oil 1. Vision 2040 global scenarios for the oil and gas industry. Shell has been a pioneer in developing scenarios to explore the future and deepen its strategic thinking for almost 50 years. A well written case study will follow a customer as they define a problem, determine a solution, implement it, and reap the benefits. Officially, i was there to attend a commemorative celebration of 30 years of scenario planning at shell.
It is in large part an adaptation and generalization of classic methods used by military intelligence. Shell s practice has now survived for almost half a century and has had a huge influence on how businesses, governments, and other organizations. Although you may not be able to use these scenarios in. To anticipate such changes, used the royal dutch shell group of companies scenario analysis, a method it pioneered three decades ago.
This work has evolved in partnership with the accreditation council for graduate medical education acgme, a relationship that continues to the present day. Scenario planning templates scenario planning examples. Redmer regent university scenario planning is a strategic planning method that organizations use to develop flexible longterm plans. Pdf strategic planning at royal dutchshell researchgate. Scenario planning is a widely used strategic planning tool. In this case, the list is pretty darn long, but much of it is quickly identifiable. Nov 19, 2015 shells approach to scenarios 6asp 2012 conference presentation scenario planning at shell oil rubenstein, baer 512012 7. Today, shell boasts a sizeable scenarios team, including experts in energy, climate change, economics, socio. The thesis is about scenario planning which was an unknown method for me. The scenario that is highest in probability should always be identified, and that ought to become the base case. Their analysis showed that in the near future, there was a great likelihood that the petroleum industry in new zealand would be deregulated. The documents contain background information on the company and its operations.
Oct 07, 2012 the application of shell scenario planning. If that proves impossible, it should at least be feasible to fashion a central case but there must be crystal clarity about the degree of certainty attached to it, the alternatives, and the resilience of any strategy to those. Answering because i m the boss or because the business case is positive was outofbounds. Three decades of scenario planning in shell case solution. This case study demonstrates that scenario planning can be.
Shell oil has been employing scenario planning practices as a way to. Despite the economic turbulence, the fundamental drivers and uncertainties explored in our shell energy scenarios to 2050 remain fully relevant. It is in large part an adaptation and generalization of classic methods used by military intelligence the original method was that a group of analysts would generate simulation games for policy makers. From the point of view of scenario planning methods as commonly understood, including as practiced and reported by royal dutch shell cornelius et al. Three decades of scenario planning in shell case solution,three decades of scenario planning in shell case analysis, three decades of scenario planning in shell case study solution, major changes in the business environment can make all the investment strategies obsolete.
In 1972, scenario planning was extended to central offices and certain large shell national operating companies. You will work on a strategic issue as part of a group for a real world client. Pdf integrating scenarios into strategic planning at. A research study on scenario planning 1567 words 7 pages.
Shell uses scenarios to develop business strategies, to identify investment opportunities and to prepare for. Cisco and monitor global business network set out to develop scenarios that answered important questions about the future of the internet. The really best part is that three decades of scenario planning in shell case study analysis is easy and really straightforward to utilize. Providing insight for impact scenario planning is a management tool that is designed to allow organizations to evaluate the efficacy of strategies, tactics, and plans under a range of possible future environments. Shells approach to scenarios 6asp 2012 conference presentation scenario planning at shell oil rubenstein, baer 512012 7. In 1965 royal dutch shell put into service what it called the unified planning machinery. Case studies scenario planning for the institute of the. Shell oil continues to be the leader in scenario planning, with a specific eye toward the impact of oil on our society, economy, and environment. Three decades of scenario planning in shell case study. Shells practice has now survived for almost half a century and has had a huge influence on how businesses, governments, and other organisations think about and plan for the future. At shell, scenarios have played an important role in projecting shifts in the global energy mix for 40 years. The origins of scenario planning as strategy development tool can be traced back to the work of herman kahn in the 1950s who conducted foresight work for the us military while working at the rand corporation the royal dutch shell company pioneered scenario planning in the corporate world, using the methodology to successfully navigate the turbulent oil crisis in the 1970s.
It contains case studies on significant scenarios that have helped expand our leaders thinking on economic, political and social challenges of their time. A case study is a special type of thought leadership content that tells a story. While the number of new cases of hivaids may be falling,1. The shelldrc study sets out a strategic aim to increase the share of gas in the. While the approach has a long history, it burst into the news in 1973. The shell scenario was the first model of business performance, planning and forecasting in written form was productive for shell oil and the oil industry was adapted and implemented in other business industries helped revolutionize business structure 2. Demand grew at 7% per year and supply was unlimited. Early in october 2002, i visited shell centre in london for an answer. Scenario planning for the future of health care and medicine since 2012, futures strategy group has been deeply involved in exploring the future of health care and medicine in the us. As part of their strategic planning process, major corporations and research firms often develop and share future scenarios specific to an industrys future or to address major global problems. The following example may be relevant to your organization. Our expert consultants in this segment have analyzed the current context of the industry and. After reading the three books about scenario planning scenario planning.
The company has invested considerable investment in the scenario process, and the. In short, it is a perfect tool for todays increasingly uncertain and volatile world. Three decades of scenario planning in shell harvard case. The authors, experienced in case study design, development, and method for teaching in an mba. The first great scenario event at shell had been a 1972 report to the managing directors anticipating the impending energy crisis. Strategic foresight and scenario planning for the future why scenarios world is complex political, economic, social, technological, ecological future is uncertain critical uncertainties weak signals forecasts are wrong predetermined elements structure given, only variables are changing possibility vs probability space scenarios are. Big corporations like shell incorporate possible shifts in global forces in their scenario planning, but the process can work just as well for a small business.
Scenario planning alerted shells managing directors its committee of. Unique to the programme is the live client case study. In that case, capacity needs to expand even further, which would cost an additional half million dollars. During the shell case study, you are presented with a number of different documents about a fictional company. In the following year, it was finally recommended throughout the group and upm was. Candidates for commercial roles are given a business scenario which they need to analyse with regard to. How do i design a fitforpurpose scenario intervention. A survey conducted by the corporate strategy board of senior managers in the year 2000 showed that scenario planning was the no. This case study demonstrates that scenario planning can be practiced effectively by organizations in the publishing industry.
Shell scenarios go beyond traditional energy outlooks to explore key drivers and trends in. Scenario planning, also called scenario thinking or scenario analysis, is a strategic planning method that some organizations use to make flexible longterm plans. In 1965, a time when quantitative, computerdriven planning was very much in vogue, royal dutch shell started experimenting with a different way of looking into the future. Strategic planning was nothing more than knowing when to build the next refinery and add a few new tankers. Scenario planning alerted shells managing directors its committee of ceo equivalents in advance about some of the most confounding events of their times. Shell scenarios since the 1970s have helped us understand how the world and its energy system could evolve in decades to come. What is the relationship between strategic planning and scenarios. Lessons from the field case studies learn from the reallife examples of two organizations applying scenario planning in different ways.
This is a major case study of scenario planning, something that is not easily available to the student of this subject. You will read about scenario planning applied both in a global context and at a notforprofit. Doodling is a kind of three decades of scenario planning in shell case study analysis because its generally not knowingly focused writing. Scenario planning at british airwaysa case study sciencedirect.
For an excellent example of strategic planning at work, consider the following case study. The corporate strategy department successfully introduced scenario planning to the airlines management during 1994 and 1995. Applying shell planning to covid19part 2 the nation. Three scenarios for planning in the era of hypercompetitiveness, energy companies will face nontraditional competitors as new participation models exploit vertical and horizontal integration opportunities within and across energy value chains to create sustainable competitive advantage. What can we learn from scenario planning at shell oil slideshare. The approach may have had more impact outside shell than within. Bmjs understanding of scenario planning is that it is a. Scenario workshops were successfully used to scenario planning at british airwaysa case study develop and link strategies between levels within a department. Integrating scenarios into strategic planning at royal dutchshell.
1006 164 1127 831 1146 737 1066 413 1079 633 596 229 1042 1329 685 663 248 1339 1093 692 289 294 1207 1127 374 1095 1340 201 852 1210 765 1178 849 1192 1186 652 590 894 553 357 1021 933 384